The antidote to your child’s smartphone addiction (and, let’s face it, your own alarming habit) is a dumb phone. The dunce of the cell market may not have all the bells and whistles to which you and your child have grown accustomed, but these talk- and text-only phones just might be the for the best. The best smartphone alternatives for kids don’t mess around with screen time-limiting apps or calls for discipline; instead, they just provide the bare essentials, limiting function to calls and texts only. Phones like these can be used for conversation, communication, and some light fun, but are free of such distractions as apps and web browsing.
Some dumb phones are reminiscent of the old brick-like cell phones you bought before that Apple device that encouraged you to tap and swipe. Others are purposefully crafted to be both beautiful and minimal, filtering out features that are standard on smartphones. And finally, there are phone alternatives, devices that let you communicate with your son or daughter without a keypad or screen. All provide talk and some provide text, but none provide easy access to social media, streaming, and social media. Bonus: The comparatively low cost of these dumb phones means you won’t need to take a second job should the device break, which may be the smartest choice of all.
While not quite 'dumb,' Nokia's latest offering is the closest we've seen to a dumbed-down smartphone. Its 4G connectivity opens up gaming, but really, unless you're talking about the included Snake, you'll have a tough time with its non-touchscreen. Bonus: In an odd quirk, the device includes FM stations, so the most dangerous thing your child might get into is talk radio.
The Relay, with its one-button communication, seems like a walkie-talkie. But with 4G LTE and WiFi connection ($7/month), it’s way more high-tech. Send the kid out with one of the brightly colored, rugged, and water-resistant squares, and you can communicate with him or her through an app on your phone or with a one-button push on a unit of your own. Unlike the traditional walkie-talkie, your channel is private, and you can track your child’s location in real-time via the app. More features are coming: Music channels administered by parental control, games, Google Relay, private channels, and voice messages are all promised.
Built to military impact specifications and waterproof, you child's well-worn excuse of having broke his or her phone won't hold up under cross-examination. While Plum's Ram 8 does have a five-megapixel camera and 4G connectability, there's no browser and only primitive texting. We love the addition of a programmable 'SOS' button for peace of mind for you and your kid.
The Jelly Pro is small — about the size of a credit card. But it’s more or less a regular smartphone, powered by the Android 7.0 Nougat operating system and including apps, GPS, messaging, gaming, and just about every other feature we’ve come to expect. So why include it on this list? Exactly because it’s small. Without a sun-blocking silhouette, kids just tend to use it less. With its size, it’s not super useful for all of those features you’ve come to expect on a smartphone, making it an ingenious method of reducing screen time and usage.
Items that are made for the most rugged conditions in the world — military, first responders, Antarctic explorers, etc. — are uniquely engineered to withstand the rigors of childhood. That’s why the XP5s makes our list. Its rugged case comes with a three-year comprehensive warranty, meaning if your child somehow manages to break it, you’re covered. Meanwhile, texting and calls are in, while browsing, apps, and streaming are out. By the time your warranty lapses, your kids will be ready for a smartphone. Note: For now, the XP5s is only available on Sprint and AT&T carriers.
Every product on Fatherly is independently selected by our editors, writers, and experts. If you click a link on our site and buy something, we may earn an affiliate commission.