I Was Spanked And Turned Out Fine, But Here’s Why I’ll Never Spank My Own Kids
"It required a greater degree of creativity and engagement to discipline without spanking."
The following was syndicated from Quora for The Fatherly Forum, a community of parents and influencers with insights about work, family, and life. If you’d like to join the Forum, drop us a line at TheForum@Fatherly.com.
What age should you stop spanking your kids?
Age zero. I have a limited sample size, but here’s my story:
I was spanked as a kid. My father did it sparingly, only at ages 4–10, where it could conceivably be useful. He explained why he was doing it in advance — he never struck me in anger or spontaneously. He hit hard enough to sting, but never hard enough to bruise. He only hit me on my buttocks. It was always for a specified purpose, and never demeaning. I was never made to feel like a “bad kid.”
When I was about to become a father for the first time, my wife and I discussed the issue at length. She had a similar experience growing up. We agreed that we would do the same for our children. Our rationale was that “sometimes it’s the only way to get the kid’s attention”.
But 2 minutes after my son was born, my wife looked at me in the eyes and said (what seemed out of the blue), “You’re never going to touch this child.” It was the post-birth oxytocin flood speaking, but she meant it.
And so we didn’t.
“You’re never going to touch this child.”
It required a greater degree of creativity and engagement to discipline without spanking, but in retrospect, that’s a feature, not a bug.
After 5 kids (okay, I’m not exactly through the process with all 5) it hasn’t been tougher or easier. I can’t say I haven’t been tempted. But we haven’t hit our kids. And the results are in line with what the research says.
It’s for the better. Don’t hit your kids.
Kevyn Nightingale is a tax account, husband, and father of 5. Read more from Quora below:
- Did you ever have an issue with your significant other on the topic of having kids? How did you work it out?
Want tips, tricks, and advice that you’ll actually use? Click here to sign up for our email.
This article was originally published on