Your Preschooler Actually Will Remember Their First Vacation, Just Not How You Think
The following was produced in partnership with our friends at Walt Disney World Resort, who invite you to discover a world of magic and memories the whole family will share.
One of the perks of being a parent is that you get to introduce your kid to the world. That’s easy when they’re an infant (a baby is basically carry-on luggage that occasionally cries), but traveling with a preschooler can require NASA-level planning. Instead, many parents simply stay put. “They’ll never remember it, anyway,” is the resigned refrain — even if they managed to successfully land their kid on the moon.
But that’s not exactly true. You’ve probably heard that children don’t form memories until about age 3, but that’s a bit of an oversimplification. According to a pair of leading experts in childhood memory, your 2-year-old may not recall their first spin on the teacups like you will (How could you forget that face?), but they will retain a different, more mysterious kind of memory — one that lasts a lifetime.
Kids Remember Things Differently Than Adults Do
Adults might think of memory in terms like, “Remember that great restaurant we went to on our honeymoon?” or “Did I forget our anniversary?” But according to Nora Newcombe, Professor Of Psychology at Temple University and Co-Director of their Infant & Child Laboratory, memory is more than a mental picture. “One of the big contributions of psychology and neuroscience over the past few decades is to unpack memories into different categories.”
The 2 categories that are most relevant to the, “To vacation or not vacation?” conundrum, Newcombe explains, are explicit memory and implicit memory. Both are subdivisions of long-term memory and begin developing very early. Here’s how they differ:
- Explicit Memory. Requires conscious recall and is generally associated with a time and a place — the autobiographical version of memory you’re used to.
- Implicit Memory. Not about specific events, but instead is more of an unconscious, emotional recollection.
Your kids remembering the pancakes you made for them on Saturdays? Explicit. The warm, fuzzy feelings whenever they pass an IHOP? Implicit. Your ability to remember what you had for breakfast this morning? Questionable.
What Is Childhood Amnesia?
Kids begin forming explicit memories around the 2-year mark, but the majority are still implicit memories until about 7-years-old. It’s what researchers, like Carole Peterson from Canada’s Memorial University of Newfoundland, call “childhood amnesia.”
She says that 3, or about preschool age, is the turning point when explicit memories begin to get more frequent, detailed, and adult-like. By age 6 or 7, your kid’s memory is similar to yours. (So, maybe your 8-year-old can help you remember what you ate this morning?)
It Doesn’t Matter If They Don’t Remember
Don’t judge an experience by whether or not your preschooler will cherish it forever. ”If the kid has fun, even if they don’t remember the experience, that’s nothing to sneeze at in terms of forming a worldview that life can be enjoyable,” says Newcombe. “It sets a global expectation that the world is a nice place and people are good to me. These are the kinds of things people are building up in the early years.”
Form Collective Family Memories
Your kid, thankfully, won’t remember their birth. But if you keep bringing up that story about how you raced their mom to the hospital in the worst blizzard of the century, they’ll have a memory of the event as if they white-knuckled the drive right beside you. “It becomes part of their memory, too,” Newcombe says. “In some sense, this is a false memory because they didn’t experience it, but it’s a true memory because it did happen.”
She says that in experiments, researchers have found that it’s possible to introduce false details into people’s memories. “It’s both good and bad that our memories are plastic,” says Newcombe. “We can incorporate new things, but we have to remember that our memories are fallible.” So, scrapbook responsibly.
Reinforce Those Good Memories
Very few people have enough brain RAM to recall everything that happens in their life. But, according to Peterson, memories that are suffused with emotion and fit into a greater context are more likely to form earlier and last longer. You can help this process by talking to your kids about experiences from their lives. “Kids’ memories are more coherent when there’s a context of who, what, where, when, why, and how,” says Peterson. It turns out your folks were onto something with those vacation slideshows.
Get Nostalgic With Your Kids
Memory experts are beginning to think that parents who talk a lot about the past play a big role in the number of memories kids form and how early they form them. This may be especially true for fathers and sons.
Peterson conducted a study of parental influence on early memories that particularly examined the effect of gender-specific parent-child combinations. In the experiment, young adults (ages 18-28) were asked to recall as many memories involving parents as they could from their preschool years (before age 6). “We found that when you had warm parents that spent a lot of time talking about the past, those males remembered more of early life, but also had memories from farther back in their lives,” Peterson says. “And that’s particularly the case for fathers talking to sons.”
The next time you look at your preschooler and think, “they’ll never remember this,” you’re right — they probably won’t. But take comfort in the fact that just because they won’t have total recall about these formative years, they will remember the important things that make them better people: parents take care of you, the world is a good place, and life is fun. Especially when the teacups start picking up some speed.