If you’ve been tossing and turning a little too much but aren’t ready for the expense and hassle of replacing your mattress, a mattress topper is a relatively cheap and easy way to improve the quality of your shuteye.
Like mattresses themselves, mattress pads come in a range of options. It’s because of the wide variety of mattress toppers that even the pickiest of sleepers can find one that suits them, whether their priority is to cool off, sink in, or firm up their sleeping surface.
And even if you have a near-perfect mattress, a mattress topper is still a useful item that can help you customize your bed, making it that much more pleasant (and a solid alarm clock even more of a necessity). Here are some of the best mattress pads no matter your preferences.
Call this one the Rolls-Royce of mattress toppers. The Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR Supreme 3-Inch Premium Foam Mattress Topper is the top pick on our list. It's also the priciest, but in this case, as in most others, you get what you pay for.
Pros: Because it’s made from three inches of the foam used on the full mattresses, you get all the same benefits, including the custom shaping to your body, temperature management, and hygiene. The latter is thanks to a washable, allergen-resistant cover. Plus, it’s an investment piece of sorts. How, you ask? Instead of shelling out for a new mattress, you can trick out your current one to be truly flawless.
Cons: The price. Wow, the price. For the cost of a Tempur-Pedic mattress pad you can get a whole new mattress from a less expensive brand. There’s also a small break-in period to expect as your topper adapts to you, not unlike wearing a new pair of leather shoes.
One Fatherly editor has this mattress topper, which has transformed an otherwise too-firm bed into a plush oasis that's just soft enough.
Pros: It’s easy to use. You stick it on top of your mattress and it instantly conforms to your body. If you tend to get hot at night, this mattress pad has gel beads that help keep you cool. And the memory foam helps align your body. You can choose between the two-inch and three-inch option.
Cons: It can go flat in time, and it can move around if you’re a toss-and-turn sleeper.
Contrary to what its name suggests, the Duck & Goose mattress topper is made from a synthetic down fiber to create a topper akin to those used by your grandparents. The two-inch pad has a more natural feel than foam options.
Pros: This topper feels substantially different than others on this list, adding some softness and better warmth. As previously mentioned, it avoids the pitfalls of foam toppers while having the added benefit of not divoting over time. While hypoallergenic and antibacterial, it’s also machine-washable—try doing that if your foam model gets soiled. And while it claims it doesn’t have the propensity for hot spots like foam, it is nevertheless super-warm and a cozy pick for chilly winter nights.
Cons: While D & G’s offering may add softness, it provides zero support, suggesting that those with back issues should keep looking. Also, because it’s one of the thinnest on this list, some may find it doesn’t alter the feel of their existing mattress enough to justify the expense.
One of the best things about this topper is the fact that it comes in four differnt thicknesses, so you can get the right amount of foam for you.
Pros: Green tea extract and castor natural seed oil are integrated into the foam, each helps eliminate odor-causing bacteria for a fresher smelling bed.
Cons: This topper is on the firmer side, so you won’t sink into it like you would a normal memory foam topper. Those who want a soft sleeping surface should look elsewhere.
As the best of both worlds, ViscoSoft’s Four-Inch Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper combines two tried-and-true topper compounds. You get a gel-infused foam base with a quilted, plush topper cover. At four inches thick, it’s also one of the heftiest on this list.
Pros: Gel-infused toppers anecdotally provide the same cushion of traditional foam cores without the possibility of overheating. We also loved the quilted coverlet that keeps everything sanitary and machine-washable.
Cons: Man, this thing is heavy, clocking in at almost 20 pounds for the twin size alone (around four times the weight of a standard topper). If convenience and portability is a factor, there are lighter options on the market.
A down alternative mattress topper that's great for those who enjoy breakfast in bed.
Pros: Spills of less than 200 milliliters won’t soak through the cotton layer into the down alternative fill. And if you do have a larger issue you can throw this thing in the washing machine.
Cons: This pad is a good choice for making your mattress a bit softer, but it’s not great if you need a lot of extra support.
If you’ve ever dealt with an uncomfortable hotel bed, you’ll appreciate your houseguests’ need to customize the spare room’s mattress. Olee’s Sleep Tri-Folding Memory Foam Topper comes in a foldable design for easy storage under an average bed frame when not needed.
Pros: If rarely use a topper, are dealing with an injury that is eased by one, this storable design might be a good option. It’s handy, and easily hidden. Take our word for it: traditional toppers, while arriving in small packages, never go back in them.
Cons: Ever met someone who says he or she has too much storage available? Neither have we. If you plan on leaving a topper on nonstop, why purchase a foldable design? For sensitive sleepers, there’s also a possibility of feeling the segments.
Fans of ice cream will immediately understand the appeal of the DreamFoam Bedding Two-Inch Gel Swirl Memory Foam Topper: It's a blend of the best.
Pros: Traditional foam toppers provide structure and support; gel toppers are great for cooling and soothing. DreamFoam’s topper combines both of them, and the company claims it helps increase airflow while cooling, supporting, and cushioning.
Cons: Great performance doesn’t always have longevity, and some reviewers dinged it for not maintaining its standard year after year. As we noted earlier, you get what you pay for, and this topper’s price tag suggests it’s too good to be true (for very long).
Every product on Fatherly is independently selected by our editors, writers, and experts. If you click a link on our site and buy something, we may earn an affiliate commission.