The following was syndicated from Quora for The Fatherly Forum, a community of parents and influencers with insights about work, family, and life. If you’d like to join the Forum, drop us a line at [email protected].
Should you raise girls differently than boys?
Today, in 2016, as a mother of 4 children, I’m going to say yes, you should raise girls differently than boys. You should not have to. But to deal with this world, today, you should raise girls differently than boys.
It’s not ideal. It’s unfortunate. But it’s true.
I have 3 sons. I have one daughter.
I am going to teach all of my children, to the best of my ability, to be strong. To be thinkers. To stand up for what’s right. To be kind and loving, generous and forgiving. To use their minds. To remember to enjoy life, not just keep working towards some ultimate goal and forget about living in the day also.
But I’m going to raise my daughter a little differently from my sons.
I want them all to be good people. Strong people. To be as prepared for the world as it stands and as it may be as they can be.
And that means different things right now.
In 2016, there are still stereotypes to be dealt with. The media and pop culture still influence my children in ways I may not always anticipate or choose. There are still plenty of people in our lives trying to toughen up my sons and soften my daughter. That want the boys not to cry. That want my daughter to wear pink frills.
I have to raise my daughter to fear for her body and her personal space in a way that I don’t have to with my sons.
Some of that is okay. There are times when we just can’t cry, even if we want to — all of us, girls and boys. There are times and places for pink frills, if you so choose them — girls or boys.
I want my daughter to be tough and strong. She wears Star Wars shirts and her brothers’ outgrown, soft little race car boxer briefs. She wears dresses, too, when she wants to, and revels in a skirt with pockets (just like me). But I am teaching her also that it’s okay for her to yell if she needs to. To fight when she feels she needs to. There are still pressures for her to be quiet and kind always. Demure. Sometimes, it’s okay for her to be loud. To be assuming. To stridently out-yell her brothers in a game. And I’m teaching my sons that it’s okay to be out-yelled by a girl. To listen to her directions sometimes even though she’s younger and a girl. That there’s nothing wrong to losing to girls. This all sounds like ‘duhhhh’ stuff — but it isn’t. Not even today, in 2016, with all the advances and in a fairly enlightened society here in Silicon Valley.
The truth is, the world is still hard on girls. For all the talks I have with fellow women in the workplace and leadership roles about how women can and should be strong and assertive, the reality remains that there’s still a price to it. And because I want my daughter to have choices and to be equipped for success, even if it’s not always great, I am also teaching her how to temper things.
I have to teach her first to stand up for herself. To be assertive and clear. But I will also teach her alternative ways for when she’s dealing with people who just can’t or won’t with a woman like that. Not because I think it’s right, but because sometimes, in 2016, if you’re a woman, you still have to be able to conform, or you might find yourself performance managed out. Passed over for promotions. Marked as being difficult to work with. And all just because you forgot to say “I feel like … “ or “I’m not sure, but I was thinking that…” when you just mean “I know this to be true.”
For every time my sons can just state their thoughts and opinions, I know that there’s a chance that their sister won’t be able to do the same. And so, I have to teach her to be able to state things but also how to coach it into a softer message just in case. Because someday, she may just need to get her point across any way she can and she may not have the social equity to just say it like a man would.
I have to emphasize 2 different points in each story in order to get my kids to a place where they are all in the middle ground of the 2 stereotypes.
And so, I teach my sons that it’s okay for a girl to say things like they do. To be blunt and clear. To argue with them. To tell them they’re wrong. I teach them that it’s ok to admit to being wrong. To apologize. To be humble. I teach her all of those things too — but I am careful. I know how easily she’s going to learn those lessons on her own from the world. So where my sons need a heavier touch from me, because media and society will accept things from them that they won’t from a girl, my daughter needs a lighter touch. She has to know how to do it in case she needs to, but she needs me not to break her of the habits of being outspoken. Society will try to do that, so I have to make sure I don’t. They’re going to hammer her for not smiling, while they’ll tell my sons that smiling too much makes them look weak (Hillary Clinton’s ‘Angry’ Face).
I have to raise my daughter to fear for her body and her personal space in a way that I don’t have to with my sons. Yes, there are risks and dangers for them, and we have talked about that and will continue to as they get older. But it’s not the same as what my daughter will deal with. (Reference: When was the first time you were groped or sexually assaulted as a woman?) There are situational awareness things that she will need to know that my sons never will, not at the same level (but yes, I’ll teach them anyways so they can help watch out for other at-risk people and so they know how to not be part of the problem).
The world I live in today is different if you’re living as a woman than a man. I don’t like it. I will do everything in my power to change it, to influence this next gen through my children, so that it changes. But the world is slow to change. And in order to get to a point where everyone is safe and equal, it means reinforcing some things in my daughter that I will try to tone down in my sons, and vice versa. It means countering social media, media, and culture around us in different ways. It means not letting my daughter always get cast as a princess and not always letting my sons be the white knights. It means teaching my daughter that it’s okay and right for her to save people. It means teaching my sons that it’s okay and right sometimes for them to be saved by others, and women.
Sometimes, I have to emphasize 2 different points in each story in order to get my kids to a place where they are all in the middle ground of the 2 stereotypes.
The media and pop culture still influence my children in ways I may not always anticipate or choose.
I don’t know if I’m right. No parent really does. All I know is that as great as it sounds to raise them exactly the same, I don’t know if that will work, because the world around us is not following this pattern, and it’s not enough for me just to do what should theoretically be right — I have to actively also counterbalance the outside influences. I’m just doing the best I can in a scary world for all my children, which is all any parent can do, really.
And in this world, as I see it, that means sometimes raising my girl differently than my boys.
Alecia is an accomplished writer who has been published by Forbes, the Huffington Post, Thought Catalog, and more. See more of her Quora posts here:
- What are your experiences when coping after your child was diagnosed with autism?
- Why do some people have teal-colored pumpkins outside their houses for Halloween?
- How do you get a toddler to do what you want him or her to do without bribing, threats, or physical coercion?